Israel’s Retention of Palestinian Bodies: A Silent ‘Hostage-Taking’

Introduction: The Unseen Captives

In a modest house in Qarawat Bani Hassan, a West Bank the town, 3 younger boys—elderly six, 9, and 11—take a seat in silence on a settee with their grandmother, Aziza. They are taking note of a tale they’ve heard again and again, a tale with out an finishing. It is the tale in their father, Abdul Rahman Mari, a 34-year-old artisan who died in an Israeli jail in November 2023 after seven months of pre-trial detention. He used to be accused of a criminal offense he denied. According to testimonies from fellow detainees, he used to be most likely crushed to demise through his jailers. His circle of relatives used to be denied a funeral. For over two years, his frame has been withheld through Israeli government. "The children ask where their father is, they ask where his body is," Aziza informed human rights investigators, her voice breaking. "We do not have the courage to ask for him again because we are afraid of the occupying army."

This isn’t an remoted tragedy. It is a window right into a pervasive and deeply distressing coverage: the systematic retention of deceased Palestinians through Israeli forces. This observe transforms mortal stays into tools of energy—gear for punishment, mental struggle, and eventual negotiation leverage. While the sector witnessed the kidnapping of Israeli our bodies through Hamas on October 7, 2023, a parallel, continuously overpassed fact persists within the occupied territories. This article supplies a complete, evidence-based exam of Israel’s frame retention coverage. We will discover its human penalties, its criminal contours beneath worldwide humanitarian legislation, its historic roots, and its serve as as a silent type of "hostage-taking" that perpetuates cycles of trauma and undermines chances for peace. Our research attracts on forensic experiences, testimonies from rights organizations like B’Tselem and Al-Haq, Israeli army orders, and binding worldwide criminal statutes to provide a transparent, factual, and pedagogical account of this essential factor.

Key Points: Understanding the Crisis

The Core Practice: Policy or Ad-Hoc Measure?

Israel’s retention of Palestinian our bodies isn’t a sporadic or unintentional incidence. It is a systematic coverage carried out through the Israeli army and jail government. Bodies are withheld for extended sessions, continuously for months or years, formally cited beneath wide "security reasons" or "public order" justifications. The observe happens each within the West Bank, the place folks would possibly die right through arrest, army operations, or in custody, and inside of Israel’s jail gadget. Crucially, the go back of our bodies is in most cases conditional, continuously tied to the circle of relatives’s behavior (e.g., restrictions on funeral dimension) or used as a bargaining chip in broader negotiations, similar to prisoner exchanges.

The Human Cost: Indefinite Grief and "Disappearance"

For households, the withholding of a beloved one’s stays creates a singular and profound agony. It denies them the basic human proper to accomplish burial rites in keeping with their spiritual and cultural traditions, a cornerstone of dignity in each Islamic and Jewish legislation. This "administrative disappearance" of the useless prolongs and intensifies trauma, combating closure. Families reside in a state of suspended mourning, not able to transport ahead, whilst the unresolved standing of the frame turns into a continuing, painful reminder of state energy and loss. Children, like Mari’s sons, develop up with a mum or dad who’s each long gone and not-gone, a ghost within the circle of relatives narrative.

Legal Status: A Clear Violation of International Law

The observe violates more than one provisions of worldwide humanitarian legislation (IHL) and human rights legislation. The Geneva Conventions, in particular the Fourth Geneva Convention relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War, explicitly offer protection to the respect of the useless. Article 33 prohibits collective consequences and intimidation, whilst the Convention’s normal ideas mandate that the useless be handled with admire and that households be told in their destiny. The Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions is much more particular, requiring events to a warfare to "take all possible measures to prevent the dead from being despoiled" and to "facilitate the return of the remains of the deceased." The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) promises the best to circle of relatives existence and freedom from merciless, inhuman, or degrading remedy, rights that stretch to the remedy of deceased relations. The UN Human Rights Council and the International Court of Justice (ICJ) have time and again affirmed that those tasks follow within the occupied Palestinian territories.

A Two-Sided Crisis: The Context of October 7 and Beyond

Any research of frame retention will have to be contextualized inside the complete scope of the Israeli-Palestinian warfare. The abhorrent observe of Hamas and different armed teams taking the our bodies of Israelis killed on October 7, 2023, is a battle crime and a profound violation of worldwide legislation, inflicting immense struggling to Israeli households. However, the lifestyles of 1 violation does now not negate or justify any other. Israel’s long-standing coverage of conserving Palestinian our bodies constitutes a separate, systemic violation. Both practices contain the usage of human stays as political leverage, making a grim symmetry of abuse that fuels mutual hatred and makes reconciliation harder. Addressing one calls for addressing the opposite.

Background: The Evolution of a Policy

To perceive the prevailing, one will have to glance to the previous. Israel’s coverage of holding the our bodies of Palestinians didn’t emerge spontaneously; it’s rooted within the criminal and safety framework of a 57-year army profession.

Historical Precedents: From the First Intifada to the Present

Documentation through Palestinian and worldwide human rights organizations signifies that the observe has been hired in quite a lot of paperwork since no less than the First Intifada (1987-1993). During sessions of heightened warfare, the collection of withheld our bodies spikes. Following the Second Intifada (2000-2005), the coverage turned into extra institutionalized. Israeli army orders, such because the "Order Concerning Security Provisions" (Judea and Samaria, No. 378), grant commanders extensive discretion to withhold our bodies for "security investigation" functions, a time period with out a transparent criminal definition or cut-off date. In observe, this has allowed for indefinite retention.

Legal Architecture in Israel

Within Israel’s home criminal gadget, the coverage is ruled through a mixture of army legislation appropriate to the occupied territories and jail rules. The Israel Prison Service operates beneath its personal inside pointers, which were criticized for a loss of transparency. Israeli courts, together with the Supreme Court, have heard petitions from households. In some rulings, the court docket has ordered the go back of our bodies after a length, nevertheless it has constantly upheld the state’s authority to retain them for "security needs," successfully sanctioning the coverage. This home criminal validation stands in direct pressure with Israel’s tasks beneath the worldwide treaties it has ratified.

The Scale of the Problem

While exact numbers are tough to establish because of a loss of respectable Israeli transparency, human rights teams have compiled important information. Organizations like B’Tselem and Al-Haq have documented masses of instances over the last twenty years. As of early 2024, experiences indicated that over 300 our bodies of Palestinians have been being held through Israeli government. The retention sessions range, however instances of our bodies held for over a yr are not unusual, and a few, like that of Abdul Rahman Mari, had been held for greater than two years. These figures constitute handiest the recognized instances; the real quantity could also be upper.

Analysis: Why Are Bodies Withheld? Motives and Mechanisms

The Israeli state formally cites &quot